Reception Įric Goldman of IGN gave the episode a 7.4 saying that "there were quite a few funny moments and scenes" but it "lacked a certain spark and energy and felt fairly low key for a season finale in general". Under the guise of doing the Curb show, it was very relaxed and loose and easy." The original sets were used to reconstruct Jerry's apartment and Monk's Café, with Jerry's apartment updated to reflect the 11 years that had elapsed since "The Finale". He stated that it "was a perfect way to do something like that but not to do it. Cast ĭavid previously refused to make a Seinfeld reunion, but he thought it would be funny to do it on Curb Your Enthusiasm. In the episode, Jerry says "we already screwed up one finale", a reference to the fact that " The Finale" was not well received by critics or fans. Most of the reunion show revolves around George attempting to get back with Amanda, who received half of George's money and would want a prenuptial agreement to ensure he did not get together just for the money. In the years since the original finale, Jerry donated sperm to have a daughter with Elaine the child, unknowingly, calls him "Uncle Jerry", but learns the truth by the end of the episode and eventually calls him "daddy".
His wife left him before he lost his fortune in the Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme, and George then moved in with Jerry. The Seinfeld reunion show centered on George Costanza, who married a woman named Amanda and made a fortune by devising an iPhone application called the iToilet, which directed the user to the nearest decent public toilet anywhere in the world (in " The Busboy", an actual Seinfeld episode, George brags about being able to find "the best public toilet anywhere in the city"). The two kiss until Larry notices a ring stain caused by Cheryl's drink, subsequently accusing Cheryl of causing the ring stain on the antique table. Larry states that he prefers the original ending to the one he had written, which causes Cheryl to say "because belong together", much like Larry and Cheryl. Cheryl then knocks on his door, stating she quit the show after arguing over the small size of Jason's book, and also because "it wasn't the same" since Larry's resignation. Upon watching the show's premiere, Larry is surprised to see that Virginia is in fact playing Amanda.
In the parking lot, Larry talks to Jeff on the phone and mentions that the only reason he had put the show together to begin with was to have a chance to get back together with Cheryl, which she overhears from her car. This causes Jason to leave the set when the rest of the cast wants Jason to return, Larry unsuccessfully tries to play George himself, and quits the show shortly thereafter. In retaliation, he rewrites the ending of the show, in which George and Amanda do not end up together.
The two begin to develop a very friendly relationship, leaving Larry jealous. Larry misses the date when he attempts to repair his friendly relationship with Mocha Joe (the studio lot's coffee guy whom Larry failed to tip), causing Cheryl to turn to Alexander for coaching. While on the set of the show, Cheryl invites Larry to her house to review the script. Larry claims his innocence and refuses to pay for the damages, and thus decides to find the person responsible the person who does not "respect wood." At the party, Julia Louis-Dreyfus accuses Larry of leaving a "ring stain" on an antique table in her house. Meanwhile, Julia Louis-Dreyfus holds a party in honor of Jason's book release, Acting Without Acting, which Larry David and Jerry Seinfeld criticize for being too short. He previously cast her in the Seinfeld reunion show as Amanda, ex-wife of George, played by Jason Alexander.
Larry David is hopeful that his plan is working to win back his ex-wife Cheryl ( Cheryl Hines).